Monday, December 10, 2007

Information Wants To Be Free

According to Wikipedia, this phrase was supposedly first pronounced by Stewart Brand in 1984, citing the fact that the cost of dissemination is getting lower and lower. However, the effort required to generate high-quality information ain't getting any cheaper.

But equally a lot of people view their information as free for dissemination as they make their money in other ways, like IKEA. You could say the likes of Google are parasitic and without information to search they wouldn't be able to sell advertising space, but I would argue it more of a symbiotic relationship. The concept of consolidating freely available information then selling easy access i.e. adding value is as old as the Bible.

With the trend towards Open Source the argument goes that enabling technology like operating systems and other basic building blocks that benefit everyone should be free so that, like Isaac Newton, you can reach greatness by 'standing on the shoulders of giants' rather than reinventing the wheel. I think there is a strong argument that if public money is spent on R&D then the IP should be made freely available. However, those who create valuable information (and whose business model requires payment) deserve to have their copyright and commercial integrity respected.

Thursday, December 06, 2007

Convergence: Jack of All Trades or Master of One?

The whole TV/Broadband/Mobile/MP3 world sees to be heading for one point on the sunrise aimed at producing one appliance that is all things to all men: Whether its one box or one handset it has to do it all. This reminds me of the eternal battle ensuing in the software space between ERP systems (get you systems and processes right, then pore concrete on them) versus best-of-bread applications (malleable components linked together using open integration technologies allowing swap and change). It invariably boils down to whether you want something that is 90% good at doing lots of things or many things that are 100% good at doing just one.

In an earlier post, I talked about focus, focus, focus. Think of the last 10% being innovation and the 90% being the existing substance. For some markets the benefits of the innovation offset the complexity of having multiple vendors; for others simplicity and consistency is the name of the game. For most innovators, a market that has developed to this point of maturity is not a good place to be as you will face an uphill battle to see off the entrenched competition who will undoubtedly cover more bases than you do. So you need to find a peripheral market, which is undoubtedly smaller, where your value proposition can hold sway against the entrenched competition. When you are starting out, don't seek to be a jack of all trades, be master of one.

Thursday, November 29, 2007

First Mover Disadvantage

One of the interesting themes discussed at TechTalk in association with our Investment Forum in Sheffield yesterday was that he who dares doesn't always win. Being first to market can mean you do all the R&D, validate the idea and educate potential users only to see the competition eat your carefully prepared lunch. Equally, being best technically doesn't necessarily equal success either.

As Lee Strafford emphasised as he spoke about his success story at Plusnet, route to market can be a real differentiator when it comes to execution. Stuart Green CEO of ZOO Digital warned that while you are evangelising about how beneficial your innovation will be to users, potential competitors will be readying themselves to shoot arrows in your back. And Steve Barnes, CEO of Infoserve reminded us that history is littered with those that tried first and failed or thought being (second) best equals success. Oracle didn't have the first relational database and VHS wasn't the best video technology, but each ended up the 800lb gorillas in their respective markets.

Being at the bleeding, rather than the leading, edge can leave you exposed if the market or infrastructure just ain't ready. Equally stealing a march on the competition is what innovation is all about, so this all has to be finely judged. Being first or best certainly isn't a prerequisite for commercial success.

Friday, November 23, 2007

There Be Dragons Ahead

At the Business North West event, Doug Richards of Dragon's Den fame gave a inspirational talk charting his ups and downs (yes even he has them!). Mainly anecdotal, but some of his take home messages that particularly resonated with me were:

  1. Luck and serendipity plays its part in any successful venture; the path to greatness is not deterministic. Deal with it.

  2. Don't only listen to those that have only tasted success; they are the exceptions not the rule. Also take council from people that have tasted failure as well. Inductive learning requires negatives as well as positives.

  3. Yes, have a cunning well thought-out plan but be prepared to deviate from it as necessary (recognising this is not what funders necessarily want to hear): The reality is that you have to be flexible and opportunitistic (which is what the big boys aren't, so you have the advantage).

  4. Cash and share price are not equivalent currency: Market Cap ain't worth anything until you have exited with money in the bank.
  5. Leadership is about enpowerment. "Ask for my forgiveness not my permission". The founder/CEO should strive to be operationally redundant - he or she is generally not replicatable nor reliable. Surround yourself with people more able than you!

Pile It High...

At BarCamp Leeds last Saturday, Dean Saddler CIO at PlusNet evangelised about how you can build a web-based applications quickly and easily and one of the tricks was to repackage and reuse the same underlying technology in different market niches and applications.

His take on monetisation was that if you have been smart about development, you only have to charge sensibly and adopt a subscription model to take market share from bloatware providers charging perpetual licence fees (where have I heard that before?). He also emphasised that his development plan only extended as far as the next round of features that users had requested. Sounds like the whole concept of component reuse and evolutionary development has finally caught up with web designers!

Not sure I totally agree you can produce something of any substantial worth so cheaply - even if you outsource development to China - but the idea that you have to work smart, reuse components, adopt incremental development strategies that keep you close to the users and offer something significantly better and cheaper than what has gone before is undoubtedly true.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Yorkshire Means Business

Nice to see former Yorkshire Post Business Editor David Parkin's new venture hit the streets (OK its virtual equivalent!) this week. http://www.thebusinessdesk.com/ aims to bring news, information and events about and for the business community based in Yorkshire. Needless to say I have signed up for news alerts and it will be interesting to see how this venture progresses versus more traditional publications, not least the YP!

As with my previous post on monetising online communities, the key to such a venture will be how to produce content at reasonable cost and in the business model who pays for what, when. I am sure he has done his numbers -particularly as Colin Glass is his Finance Director!

Monday, November 19, 2007

The Second Bounce

Ronald Cohen of Apex fame argues in his new book that the everyone can see the first bounce of the ball; it's the second bounce that is uncertain. And it is only in situations of uncertainty that significant investment gains can be made. Well I beg to differ - until you bounce the ball once there is the highest degree of uncertainty - one can only guess at the outcome. Once you have seen a bounce, you have data to predict pretty well what the next bounce will do and even fix things that fall flat!

Releasing Version 1 of a product into a market is always the most uncertain stage. Once users have something to play with they can give you feedback and the whole market research process can be brought to bear on the problem. When all you have is ideas, hand waving and hopefully some passion and a committed team, most potential users will still just stare back blankly at you - they ain't good at looking at a blank canvas and saying what will make it a masterpiece.

That thought dovetails pretty nicely with a talk I caught on the first bounce at BarCamp Leeds on Saturday on the futility of trying to predict the future. Sure, it's hard but unless you can make an educated guess at where things are going how can you ever hope to align the technology idea you are working on with what the future holds. That said, the prevailing view was that the best way of predicting the future is to implement it!

Monday, November 12, 2007

Monetising Digital Communities

With the rise of Web 2.0 promoting participation, sharing and collaboration it still requires that someone pays for it all. Advertisers may now be able to target viewers by their individual profile and as pay per view gives way to pay per response the theory goes that communities means money. Subscriptions are another way of generating revenue and the great thing about online is that you can collect this little and often or integrate a smorgasbord of premium services at a price, while maintain the ethos of everything being free at the point of delivery. Taking a percentage requires an online transaction, but for some communities this may be part of the business model. How to gain users is always the first challenge, but how to turn users into revenue is always a bigger one!

The likes of YouTube, MySpace and Facebook (Microfoft paid about $500 per user for their stake) can put of the day they make a buck (although with the fikkle nature of consumers they might need to hurry it up) , but for others the balance between building a community and getting paid in something other than spirit is a little more pressing.

Thursday, November 01, 2007

Shifting Sands

Project Sahara is a new initiative which I am sure Lee Strafford will be plugging when he speaks at our Techtalk 2007 event in Sheffield on the 28th November. He is seeking to create a community of Web 2.0 companies across the North of England and provide a support infrastructure to maximise the potential of their early stage ideas. This will potentially incorporate physical incubator space, mentoring and all the other things an early stage business needs. In addition, they are seeking to develop a set of online tools that members of the community can contribute to and ultimately benefit from.

Wednesday, October 31, 2007

Fear Of Failure

A recent survey by Orange reported no shortage of bright ideas, but cited the lack of confidence and a fear of failure as the main reasons for sitting on their hands. Orange said that budding entrepreneurs needed more encouragement to succeed. They called on help to be given to develop talented would-be entrepreneurs and to cultivate an appetite for rational risk in the education system.

A particular focus of Connect is to help innovators hone their ideas and share best practise through our Investor Readiness workshops and mentoring schemes. The role of Proof-of-Concept funding cannot be underestimated in helping these fledgling ideas gain momentum and we continue to lobby for improved business support in this area.

Monday, October 29, 2007

Investor Readiness

The Sunday Times featured an interesting article on Investor Readiness that echoed many of the experiences that we find with people who go through our IRP programme. These are given by experienced professionals and business people who give their time freely to help young technology entrepreneurs understand their proposition from the perspective of an investor. The lessons learnt are invaluable as is the ability to share experiences with other people following a similar journey and seasoned professionals that have heard it all before. Our next IRP workshops are being held in Sheffield on the 7th and 14th November. If you fancy coming along, please contact us.

Thursday, October 25, 2007

The Value Of Networks

Metcalfe's law states that the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of those involved. The number of unique connections in a network of a number of nodes (n) can be expressed mathematically as n*(n-1)/2. Perversely, the basic tenet of modern organisational theory is how to manage this complexity and structure companies so that as they grow this proliferation of connections is managed effectively.

However, when it comes to the virtual world the more the merrier is usually the case and only when an application focused on participation and involvement reaches a certain critical mass do those involved start to interact effectively. This relates to the fact that although the number of potential connections may be large, the number of relevant connections may be much smaller. Obviously if we are talking about directed connections i.e. you know the number or address of the person you want to 'call' then all is fine and dandy, but much of the success of tools like LinkedIn and FaceBook relates to the ability of the software to facilitate members of the network finding like minded people to interact with and build up connections based on declarative information embedded in profiles. The success of using structured information to facilitate or prompt interactions is a major development over traditional web-based directory listings.

If you also think about the comparison to physical networking - what is the chance of bumping into someone at an event are inversely linked to the paucity of the network, so the focus is to maximise the focus. With online networks the goal is to maximise the number of participants and ensure relevant people find each other using the functionality of the site. With our new resource portal http://www.mydealmaker.co.uk/ we are trying to balance the focus on signing up more users with efforts to improve the functionality of the site so that users find connections of interest as the beta progresses.


By the way, we are looking for participants for focus groups to be held over lunch from 12.30-2.30pm on Wednesday 31st October and Monday 5th November at our offices in Leeds. The aim of this is to help inform our strategy for provision of online services with specific focus on our new opportunities portal http://www.mydealmaker.co.uk/. We realize this is short notice, but if you can spare the time we really would appreciate your input. We promise no homework is involved! If you would like to have your say in a physical way, please email us.

Friday, October 19, 2007

Focus, Focus, Focus

In real estate investment the mantra is location, location, location but for a startup company it should be focus, focus, focus. Far too many companies bite off more than they can chew even before they have cut their milk teeth. While big markets numbers may turn some people on, it's always better to be a master of one.

This is what Ev Williams (founder of Blogger & Twitter) has to say about this:
“Focus on the smallest possible problem you could solve that would potentially be useful. Most companies start out trying to do too many things. Focusing on a small niche has so many advantages: With much less work, you can be the best at what you do. Small things, like a microscopic world, almost always turn out to be bigger than you think when you zoom in. You can much more easily position and market yourself when more focused. And when it comes to partnering, or being acquired, there’s less chance for conflict. This is all so logical and, yet, there’s a resistance to focusing. I think it comes from a fear of being trivial. Just remember: If you get to be #1 in your category, but your category is too small, then you can broaden your scope—and you can do so with leverage.”

Most businesses need to cross the chasm from early adopters to the mainstream and that's a lot easier when you have a whole product however small, then you can start to add +1 extensions to grow your market. The downside of trying to calve off too large a slice of market real estate too early is that you never have enough substance in any specific area to transition your product or service to the mainstream which is where you will make your money - however big or small your target market is.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Jam Tomorrow

Directorbank recently announced it is taking equity stakes in young companies in lieu of their fee for placing staff. A number of Connect Yorkshire partners also work with companies on a contingency basis and look to take a stake in return for the effort they put in. Is this a good idea? It can be a good way of building trust and aligning the interests of the advisor with that of the company. I am surprised more service providers aren't prepared to take a punt and put their money where their mouth is. One our sponsors Winburn Glass Norfolk is well known for its innovative approach in this area.

Taxing Times

The Chancellor's decision to change the Chapital Gains Tax (CGT) rate to a flat 18% and abolish taper relief seems like a gut reaction to the fact that private equity bosses are only paying 10% on their 'carry' on successful investments. Caught in the cross fire are entrepreneurs that now are going to have to pay nearly twice as much tax on exit. The fact that the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) allows up to £400K of any gain to be rolled over into a new venture softens the blow, but these changes that come in in April 2008 give a big incentive to exit before then!

Thursday, October 11, 2007

Sainsbury Boost For Connect

Lord Sainsbury’s review of the UK science and innovation system. includes a glowing endorsement of the CONNECT model:

Recommendation 9.5
Drawing on the success of the CONNECT scheme in San Diego, RDAs [Regional Development Agencies] should support services for high-technology entrepreneurs around our world-class universities similar to the CONNECT service within the BSSP [Business Support Simplification Program] framework.

Connect assists technology-based companies and entrepreneurs in refining their business and financial strategies through a group mentoring process. It assists with the development of business plans and business presentations, and provides a forum in which the entrepreneurs can present their refined business model before a group of business, marketing and management experts. The scheme’s success steams from its holistic approach, the range of expertise it provides and the fact that “none of us are as smart as all of us”.

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Distance No Object?

VCs often tell me that it’s the quality of the company that drives the deal, not the geography. So is where you start a business really that important? According to Library House London is a magnet for new venture capital backed businesses despite the expensive rent and salaries. They point to the number of successful exits as a ratio to the number of deals done as an outcome measure. Apparently, in London the ratio is 2:3 whereas in the North the ratio is no more than one in four. Does this in any way relate to the geographic remoteness from the major financial market? One blip in this statistical argument appears to be the Emerald Isle where, albeit from a lower base, the ratio of exits to deals is one in two. Maybe it’s the Guinness that aids the deal making!

Is one way of breaking down these geographic barriers to utilise technology more? Connect has recently released a online portal, http://www.mydealmaker.co.uk/, designed to allow companies wherever they are to pitch their investment proposition whenever they want. The idea is that even if a VC can't find the time or the rail fare to come to our Investment Forum, they can at least take a looksee at the cream of the technology crop from across the region. Equally, entrepreneurs no longer have to wait for the next Forum to come around in the hope that they get a presentation slot. We look forward to our first online investment success and to improving our ratios!

Monday, October 08, 2007

Online Research Versus Legwork

There seems to be an increasing trend to research opportunities online before expending too much physical effort evaluating the options. Who last went looking around a new neighbourhood looking for houses, rather than first having a trawl of Rightmove? Tesco have just launch a new comparision website to compete with the likes of MoneySupermarket. So there must be money in them there hills. And with MyDealMaker debuting, even venture capitalists and angel investors can get in on the act and search for entreprenurs with big ideas looking for funding that meet their search criteria.

Where will it all end? In the lead, not supprisingly, is Formula One. Car design is apparently moving from using computer simulation to validate an hypothesis to ab initio models where nothing physical is made until the computer says yes. Drug design has similarly embraced the idea that sampling chemical space is best done virtually before that expensive step of synthesising anything is taken and anyone gets their hands dirty.

Who, thirty years ago, would have believed that computers would be used for screening potential dates/mates before 'pressing the flesh'! And if you had said we would all be texting like mad, rather than videoconferencing by now you would have been laughed out of the room. As the BT futureologist at a recent YSTN event commented, maybe we should be employing more phycologists to help design new products, rather than leaving this entirely to the technologists!

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Fail Fast, Fail Early

Not the most inspiring of titles, but ask any medicinal chemist what the chances of his or her lead molecule making it through clinical trials and it's about one in ten (and falling). And no matter what anyone tells you, no one knows which development projects will fail when on the journey from the lab to your bathroom cabinet. Yes, that pill you pop for hay fever or hypertension is the result of a whole lot of great science and one big dose of good fortune.

The development strategy of big pharma embraces this fact as they seek to spend the least amount of money on the ones that don't make it. Fail fast, fail early is their mantra. So why don't they run tests in parallel (assuming it's ethical and legal) and speed up the process? Unfortunately, with these odds history and a few calculations in Excel tells you its a mug's game to try to rush perfection to much. What you need is a development pipeline (which is what equity analysts sweat about as the last blockbuster goes off patent) and then you can play the numbers game and be reasonably patient.

But wait, what about small guy who just has one or two throws of the dice and mix in a doze of commercial reality that their wonder drug or medical device has a limited market potential? And what if they don't have the luxury of funding their development from previous successes? Then they have to raise funding from VCs who don't want to wait a decade to see a return and even then the market potential may not give sufficient returns to make the investment add up financially. This is the problem facing many Healthcare Technology companies and it ain't easy to beat the numbers.

Complaining about the short time horizon and greediness of VCs is about as useful as trying to rush a product through clinical trials (and by that I mean spend more money on failures faster). It just isn't that productive. So what is the answer to this connundrum? The obvious answer is to licence more things earlier and accept a smaller slice of the pie if they make it through to market - which is what most smaller biotechs do. Alternatively, you can find a friendly source of development funds that is prepared to wait for a return and see your project through from cradle to grave - it's called working for Glaxo! But is there a third way?

Monday, September 24, 2007

InvestorQuest Final

The Saturday Yorkshire Post featured our Red Carpet Day where the 10 InvestorQuest finalists fought it out for a slice of the £1M of funding on offer. Whether they are successful in their quest only time will tell, but four walked away with £1K of consultancy support kindly donated by the event's sponsors Clarion solicitors (who hosted the event), Murgitroyd & Co, Mazars and Turnkey.

It was interesting reviewing the initial comments of the panel of investors. There concerns were less about how clever the technology was, but more about whether the IP was protectable, barriers to entry, routes to market, vertical market focus vs infrastructure play, return on investment, etc. Although each presenter was mentored prior to the event, only a minority had developed these aspects sufficiently to satisfy the investors appetite for business strategy, rather than technical detail.