Showing posts with label VCs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label VCs. Show all posts

Monday, January 19, 2009

Two Banks of a Technology Pond

The British persona tends to be self-deprecating and reserved when it comes to trumpeting our successes and rather backwards at coming forwards when it comes to converting innovation and research into commercial reality, particularly when compared to our US counterparts.

There is a tendency in the UK to wait until something is proven before investing in it, whereas the USA has more of an appetite for risk. Americans will try something new, if it works they embrace it and believe more, if it doesn't they purse another opportunity. This non-deterministic approach contracts sharply with our tendency in the UK to want to make managed stepwise progress that avoids the risk of failure. The fact of life is that no matter how carefully you plan, you can't avoid some false starts and the need to backtrack and admit making mistakes are all part of the journey.

Having lived and worked on both sides of the pond, my experience is that its the balance between three essential elements of tech success: IP, management and money. And the stigma attached to failure. In the USA there are more tech entrepreneurs prepared to back early stage ideas that VCs or bankers (right so!) wouldn't take even a first look at. This business angel involvement at proof of concept enables new ideas to get one foot out of the lab and onto the radar screen of serious funders with some management DNA already spliced in. Similarly American VCs employ (or are started up) by more tech-savvy people, rather than being top heavy with lawyers and accountants (not that these skills aren't important!). American VC tend then to step in an put serious money into fewer companies that are in better shape to progress than those in the UK enabling a more of a seamless transition from idea to commercialisation

So maybe we need a little more joined-up thinking that combines money, enterprise, innovation and management...

Friday, February 08, 2008

Nothing Ventured...

Deirdre Bounds gave a passionate talk at the Venturefest Yorkshire 2008 dinner. As a former stand up comic I expected a few more laughs, but she mainly focused on her journey from 'bedsit to boardroom'.

What was her take home message? Well mainly that if you have got an idea just do it, even if no one around you gets it: if you believe in yourself you can succeed in realising your vision. This was rather at odds with Ajaz Ahmed's talk earlier in the day where he was lamblasting government support agencies for backing 'lame duck' ideas that were destined to fail and that people shouldn't be given 'false hope' that they can become 'supermodels'

I must admit to being more with Deirdre on this one. Sure, we need to screen out the ideas and people that are just plain daft and applaud the ones that are sure fire winners (because they, like Deirdre, will fly without any outside help or an outside investor getting a slice of the action). But in the beauty contest that is innovation and enterprise, the winners and losers will sort themselves out in the marketplace (think dancefloor, not stage). Out there it's execution and the audience vote that counts: the wisdom of crowds, not the opinion of experts. In my experience, most good ideas start off looking pretty ugly or just plain daft to conventional eyes. As Deirdre says 'We need to encourage weird'.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Something for Nothing...

Surely the best deal is the one that generates the greatest return on investment. But those apparently in the know keep telling me Proof-of-Concept funds can't make money. But aren't business angels tying to make money and they are managing their own mini -POC fund. If you can make money on a small scale why, I ask, doesn't this scale up?

If you watch Dragon's Den they are always looking for the largest percentage of equity they can get. But 100% of nothing is still nothing, so you could say that it doesn’t matter whether you get 20% or 40% (this has been the argument of a few VCs who seem to cut much more generous offers than the dragons do) given most will fail.

Surely the point is that for the 1 in 10 early stage deals that really do fly, what percentage you have of that one is very much the differentiator when you come to analysing the overall portfolio returns. Is the problem then that larger funds just aren't prepared to get down and dirty with regards to valuations whereas individual business angels are very much focused on getting more for less? The fact that an early stage business will often get the cheapest money it's going to get i.e. grant funding followed immediately by the most expensive in terms of equity investment does little to help the situation!

Friday, January 18, 2008

Web 2.0 Startup - Plain Sailing

I attended the North West Startups event organised by Manoj Ranaweera in sunny Manchester - OK it was raining. Four interesting speakers. Stuart Scott-Goldstone talked about the legal aspects of a venture capital investment - necessary detail. Doug Stellmann of YFM Group gave some candid thoughts on investment from a VC perspective emphasising the importance of a stong management team that can react to change, admiting that very few investments follow closely to their business plan however perfectly crafted. The ability to sail through the trials and tribulations of a startup differentiates the winers from the losers. Paul Barraclough of Tecmentor talk on a subject close to my heart - crossing the chasm from early adopters to the mainstream and that very few companies find this plain sailing which reemphasised the need for agile management. Finally, Pam Holland ex-TeleCity reflected on her experience of staffing up a fast growth technology business - nice problem to have, but they didn't seem to have cracked the basic challenge of how to make more money the more you do. Spending money is a lot easier than making it!

On the Web 2.0 front (which was the main interest of entrepreneurs there) the prevailing view from the VCs was any application that you can code up in 3 months could be easily replicated in Bangalore or China, so from a professional investor perspective they would be unlikely to back it given so little barrier to entry. So think about creating something with a little more substance or have paying users before approaching a VC!

Monday, October 29, 2007

Investor Readiness

The Sunday Times featured an interesting article on Investor Readiness that echoed many of the experiences that we find with people who go through our IRP programme. These are given by experienced professionals and business people who give their time freely to help young technology entrepreneurs understand their proposition from the perspective of an investor. The lessons learnt are invaluable as is the ability to share experiences with other people following a similar journey and seasoned professionals that have heard it all before. Our next IRP workshops are being held in Sheffield on the 7th and 14th November. If you fancy coming along, please contact us.

Thursday, October 25, 2007

The Value Of Networks

Metcalfe's law states that the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of those involved. The number of unique connections in a network of a number of nodes (n) can be expressed mathematically as n*(n-1)/2. Perversely, the basic tenet of modern organisational theory is how to manage this complexity and structure companies so that as they grow this proliferation of connections is managed effectively.

However, when it comes to the virtual world the more the merrier is usually the case and only when an application focused on participation and involvement reaches a certain critical mass do those involved start to interact effectively. This relates to the fact that although the number of potential connections may be large, the number of relevant connections may be much smaller. Obviously if we are talking about directed connections i.e. you know the number or address of the person you want to 'call' then all is fine and dandy, but much of the success of tools like LinkedIn and FaceBook relates to the ability of the software to facilitate members of the network finding like minded people to interact with and build up connections based on declarative information embedded in profiles. The success of using structured information to facilitate or prompt interactions is a major development over traditional web-based directory listings.

If you also think about the comparison to physical networking - what is the chance of bumping into someone at an event are inversely linked to the paucity of the network, so the focus is to maximise the focus. With online networks the goal is to maximise the number of participants and ensure relevant people find each other using the functionality of the site. With our new resource portal http://www.mydealmaker.co.uk/ we are trying to balance the focus on signing up more users with efforts to improve the functionality of the site so that users find connections of interest as the beta progresses.


By the way, we are looking for participants for focus groups to be held over lunch from 12.30-2.30pm on Wednesday 31st October and Monday 5th November at our offices in Leeds. The aim of this is to help inform our strategy for provision of online services with specific focus on our new opportunities portal http://www.mydealmaker.co.uk/. We realize this is short notice, but if you can spare the time we really would appreciate your input. We promise no homework is involved! If you would like to have your say in a physical way, please email us.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Taxing Times

The Chancellor's decision to change the Chapital Gains Tax (CGT) rate to a flat 18% and abolish taper relief seems like a gut reaction to the fact that private equity bosses are only paying 10% on their 'carry' on successful investments. Caught in the cross fire are entrepreneurs that now are going to have to pay nearly twice as much tax on exit. The fact that the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) allows up to £400K of any gain to be rolled over into a new venture softens the blow, but these changes that come in in April 2008 give a big incentive to exit before then!

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Distance No Object?

VCs often tell me that it’s the quality of the company that drives the deal, not the geography. So is where you start a business really that important? According to Library House London is a magnet for new venture capital backed businesses despite the expensive rent and salaries. They point to the number of successful exits as a ratio to the number of deals done as an outcome measure. Apparently, in London the ratio is 2:3 whereas in the North the ratio is no more than one in four. Does this in any way relate to the geographic remoteness from the major financial market? One blip in this statistical argument appears to be the Emerald Isle where, albeit from a lower base, the ratio of exits to deals is one in two. Maybe it’s the Guinness that aids the deal making!

Is one way of breaking down these geographic barriers to utilise technology more? Connect has recently released a online portal, http://www.mydealmaker.co.uk/, designed to allow companies wherever they are to pitch their investment proposition whenever they want. The idea is that even if a VC can't find the time or the rail fare to come to our Investment Forum, they can at least take a looksee at the cream of the technology crop from across the region. Equally, entrepreneurs no longer have to wait for the next Forum to come around in the hope that they get a presentation slot. We look forward to our first online investment success and to improving our ratios!

Monday, October 08, 2007

Online Research Versus Legwork

There seems to be an increasing trend to research opportunities online before expending too much physical effort evaluating the options. Who last went looking around a new neighbourhood looking for houses, rather than first having a trawl of Rightmove? Tesco have just launch a new comparision website to compete with the likes of MoneySupermarket. So there must be money in them there hills. And with MyDealMaker debuting, even venture capitalists and angel investors can get in on the act and search for entreprenurs with big ideas looking for funding that meet their search criteria.

Where will it all end? In the lead, not supprisingly, is Formula One. Car design is apparently moving from using computer simulation to validate an hypothesis to ab initio models where nothing physical is made until the computer says yes. Drug design has similarly embraced the idea that sampling chemical space is best done virtually before that expensive step of synthesising anything is taken and anyone gets their hands dirty.

Who, thirty years ago, would have believed that computers would be used for screening potential dates/mates before 'pressing the flesh'! And if you had said we would all be texting like mad, rather than videoconferencing by now you would have been laughed out of the room. As the BT futureologist at a recent YSTN event commented, maybe we should be employing more phycologists to help design new products, rather than leaving this entirely to the technologists!

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Fail Fast, Fail Early

Not the most inspiring of titles, but ask any medicinal chemist what the chances of his or her lead molecule making it through clinical trials and it's about one in ten (and falling). And no matter what anyone tells you, no one knows which development projects will fail when on the journey from the lab to your bathroom cabinet. Yes, that pill you pop for hay fever or hypertension is the result of a whole lot of great science and one big dose of good fortune.

The development strategy of big pharma embraces this fact as they seek to spend the least amount of money on the ones that don't make it. Fail fast, fail early is their mantra. So why don't they run tests in parallel (assuming it's ethical and legal) and speed up the process? Unfortunately, with these odds history and a few calculations in Excel tells you its a mug's game to try to rush perfection to much. What you need is a development pipeline (which is what equity analysts sweat about as the last blockbuster goes off patent) and then you can play the numbers game and be reasonably patient.

But wait, what about small guy who just has one or two throws of the dice and mix in a doze of commercial reality that their wonder drug or medical device has a limited market potential? And what if they don't have the luxury of funding their development from previous successes? Then they have to raise funding from VCs who don't want to wait a decade to see a return and even then the market potential may not give sufficient returns to make the investment add up financially. This is the problem facing many Healthcare Technology companies and it ain't easy to beat the numbers.

Complaining about the short time horizon and greediness of VCs is about as useful as trying to rush a product through clinical trials (and by that I mean spend more money on failures faster). It just isn't that productive. So what is the answer to this connundrum? The obvious answer is to licence more things earlier and accept a smaller slice of the pie if they make it through to market - which is what most smaller biotechs do. Alternatively, you can find a friendly source of development funds that is prepared to wait for a return and see your project through from cradle to grave - it's called working for Glaxo! But is there a third way?

Monday, August 13, 2007

That Original Idea

As we embark on our InvestorQuest Challenge, we ask are you like John Nash in A Beautiful Mind (looking for that original idea that will be the basis of your business, rather than just delusional). Surprisingly, good ideas for a business are often less than original and are often pretty simple. In 1978 (yes, nearly thirty years ago) I wrote a program to play blackjack, so you could blame my 'idea' for all those Internet betting sites out there today. Simon Nixon, the founder of moneysupermarket.com, had a brilliantly simple idea to provide consumers with independent comparison of insurance products that he took from inception through to a £1B stock market flotation.

What differentiates those that succeed is often not the idea for the business, but their single minded focus to exploit an idea and find an addressable market for it. Turning a fledgling idea into a marketable product is the key and so is avoiding the pitfalls along the way. That's why when asked whether an investor is more interested in the idea or the management, often the answer is the latter. Good ideas are surprisingly plentiful, it's the ability to execute that maketh the business. That said, you need an idea!

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

Listen in

We like the SmallBizPod, a podcast for small businesses, start-ups and entrepreneurs in the UK.


The latest podcast examines the European technology/web sector and the state of venture capital on the continent with Alex Vieux, publisher of technology business magazine Red Herring.

It's definitely worth a listen...

Thursday, April 05, 2007

Join the Club

Reducing your carbon footprint has become a priority for many people in the UK and it seems investors are as keen to pump cash into all things green.


We noted that Whizzgo, the pay-as-you-go car hire business has been in the news again this week - this time with the launch of the scheme in Sheffield.

Whizzgo's concept is to provide cars to hire by the hour, at short notice, within a few minutes walking distance of a drivers home and workplace. By offering a car club service that is convenient giving up your car is now becoming a real alterative.

Managing director Charlotte Morton pitched for funding at the
Connect Yorkshire Investment Forum in November 2005 and since then, Whizzgo has netted quarter of a million pounds worth of funding from Yorkshire venture capital group Viking Fund.

It seems other investors have recongised the potential of the car club phenomenon and we noticed that
Streetcar the UK-based self-service car rental company, raised £6.4m (€9.5m) from Smedvig Capital this week.

Friday, March 23, 2007

VCT Downdraft

The Budget 2007 has put a size limit of 50 employees and a total investment of £2M for Venture Capital Trust investments, which maybe will drive dealflow into our area of activity. I don't have any stats, but I would guess previously very few VCTs would have invested in this sector and most AIM flotations will be above the VCT investment limit going forwards - a number of established AIM VCTs have already pulled their 2007/8 offerings.

How about someone creating a VCT targeted specifically at smaller technology companies with significant growth potential?

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Foolish angels rush in where the best angels fear to tread

We spotted a NESTA article discussing why VCs should invest in angel-backed deals. It makes for an interesting read and hails the smart business angel as the best way for a business to prepare for later stage investment.

Its true that the 'best of breed' angels bring far more to a business than just cash.

Surely VC's already know who the smart business angels are and are already montioring their every investment....

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

Connect Scotland

The SEP Technology Leaders Forum held in conjunction with the Connect Scotland Investment Forum features a number of influential speakers. One theme of discussion was that in the UK, unlike the USA, there is a big role to be played to connect entrepreneurs to sources of finance. The view was that in the USA VCs are "pacing the corridors of universities with checkbooks in hand".

The perception of the panel was that the difference is cultural: In the USA many VCs have technology backgrounds, while in the UK they primarily are financial beasts. Bridging the gap in understanding of the science is more important in Europe. To some extent this need is being met by the likes of IP Group and Biofusion, but the danger is that projects that don't meet their investment criteria may be constrained rather than facilitated.

Any tech-savvy VCs or university commercialisation outfits out there that have a view on this?

Thursday, March 30, 2006

Mapping Start-ups

I was reading Electronics Weekly last week, as you do, and noticed their ‘start-up map’. Listing all the young electronic businesses across the UK, it was really interesting to look at their geographical spread.

I’m afraid the Yorkshire region doesn’t exactly look like a hot bed of emerging technology within this sub-sector of technology. In total 5 companies were based within the boundaries of Yorkshire. Although I didn’t find this particularly surprising what did astound me were the numbers of companies coming out of the South East. 24 businesses were listed under Cambridge alone. No wonder we have difficultly persuading VCs to travel ‘up north’ - they have exciting investment prospects on their doorstep, and plenty of them.

That said, I know that the majority of companies that access Connect Yorkshire’s services have an IT base. Yorkshire definitely has greater activity within other sub-sectors of the technology industry, particularly within the digital and creative areas. Looking at the number of start-ups in the electronics sector in isolation is therefore not a true reflection of Yorkshire’s high tech talent. Our last Investment Forum in November proved that high quality deals in a sizable number are there for the taking.

For me what the map highlights is the power of transcending traditional regional boundaries particularly when attracting big spenders from the south. The North East had 4 businesses listed whilst the Manchester area had 6. If this start-up activity were pooled with Yorkshire’s 5 businesses then the pulling power of the north would be greater. Perhaps then it would be easier to convince a VC the train journey was worth the time and expense!

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

YORKSHIRE’S TECHNOLOGY SECTOR 2020

Technology has been a buzz word in Yorkshire’s economic strategy for a number of years now. Technology is seen as an industry that has the potential to revitalise sub-regional economies, following the withdrawal of traditional industries. However despite all of this hype Yorkshire and Humber is still ranked eighth in a table of the most innovative regions in the UK.

So, how will the next 14 years shape up for the technology sector? I would argue that it depends largely on a change in culture among both our students at schools and universities and in business.

Creating the entrepreneurial attitude takes a lot of change. When you get right down to it, the attitudes of the young come from their role models, parents and teachers. We need to encourage our schools to celebrate British business success, and create a different attitude towards entrepreneurship.

A great example of a different attitude is America’s approach to business failure; I understand that in the US venture capitalists don’t like investing in you unless you’ve had at least one business failure. Here they turn up their nose at anyone whose company has gone onto insolvency. The Americans like those who have had the hard experience of trouble and the bottle to try again.

At Connect Yorkshire we prime technology companies for investment and growth. Every year about 40-50 technology companies attend our various programmes. The vast majority of these have been started by people who have been working in an industry for 10 or more years. They see a gap in the market, or a new development not being exploited by their employer, and try to build a technology business to fill that gap. Contrary to popular belief, the majority of new technology businesses do not come out of universities.

Universities by their very nature concentrate on academic research, and not on business creation. Research funding largely comes from the public sector, and is awarded purely on the quality of research – as judged by other academics, not on how much a university has contributed to the regional or national economy.

The way to ensure a better research to innovation ratio is to increase the amount of research inspired by commercial needs. This is where funding from research–led businesses is invaluable.
At the heart of the issue is that while research and innovation – defined as the commercial exploitation of ideas - maybe symbiotic, they are not synonymous; research does not necessarily yield innovation.

Over the last 20-30 years we have had three major technology businesses in Yorkshire, Systime in the 80’s, and Pace and Filtronic have continuing success from the 90’s to today. Systime employees have gone on to found numerous IT businesses in their own right. A few more success stories on this scale will give the technology sector in 2020 a significant boost.

Local medical device companies harbour a huge wealth of talented scientists; individuals experienced in product development, regulatory and advanced manufacturing. Johnson and Johnson Wound Management in Gargrave, Smith and Nephew in York and Hull and Depuy in Leeds are huge international companies with a strong footing in the region. Could it be by 2020, Yorkshire is considered the hub of Britain’s medical device industry?

It’s a strong possibility and emerging companies such as Cell Tran, Ullsys, and Avanticare prove with the correct support anything is possible. Success breeds success and if Yorkshire is perceived as a centre of medical device excellence the battle of attracting and then retaining key individuals to the region will be a lot easier. This will be helped by the activities of IP2IPO at Leeds and York Universities and Bio Fusion at Sheffield University.

These White Rose universities have the ability to support a flourishing medical device industry as we head towards 2020. In addition, I believe there will be many more technology businesses coming out of the students from Sheffield Hallam, Leeds Met, Hull, Bradford and the other non White Rose universities.